Election Years and the Markets

Sean Casterline
2 min readMar 25, 2024

The performance of the stock market during election years has been a subject of keen interest among investors and analysts alike. Historical trends suggest that the behavior of the stock market in these periods is influenced by the uncertainty surrounding political changes and policy expectations. But, in the end, markets have faired well during election years, averaging around 10% per year in our country’s history.

Historical Patterns and Election Cycles: Traditionally, election years have been characterized by increased market volatility. This volatility often stems from the uncertainty of election outcomes and the potential shifts in government policies that can impact various sectors of the economy. For example, different administrations might have different policies on trade, taxation, and regulation, which can significantly affect investor sentiment and market performance.

Impact of Political Parties: Conventional wisdom suggests that the market favors certain political outcomes over others. However, historical data indicates that the stock market’s performance is not consistently better under one party than the other. While it’s a common belief that Republican administrations are more business-friendly, leading to bullish markets, and Democratic administrations favor regulatory and social welfare policies, potentially leading to bearish markets, the reality is often more complex and influenced by broader global and economic factors.

Sector Rotations: Depending on which party is leading during the election cycle, you may see sectors rotating in and out of favor. Sectors like healthcare and defense are typically big areas of focus and this can cause a heightened level of volatility in those specific sectors.

The Role of Economic Indicators: Economic indicators such as GDP growth, unemployment rates, and consumer confidence play a crucial role in shaping market performance during election years. A strong economy might lead to a more favorable market reaction, irrespective of the political party in power.

Predictability and Market Reaction: Markets dislike uncertainty, and election years are inherently uncertain. Unexpected election outcomes or political events can lead to significant market reactions. Conversely, when election outcomes align with market expectations, the reaction may be muted.

While election years bring a certain degree of unpredictability and volatility to the stock market, historical trends suggest that the long-term impact of election outcomes on market performance is often overshadowed by broader economic factors. In the end, election years tend to experience good market performance but they also tend to experience a heightened level of volatility. So, buckle your seat belts!

--

--

Sean Casterline

Wealth Manager at Delta Capital Management located in Maitland, Fl.